Thick green lawn shaded by trees in front of a brick home in Massachusetts

What's the Difference Between Organic and Organic-Based Lawn Care?

The difference between organic and organic-based lawn care is synthetic fertilizers and the use of targeted weed and insect control: organic lawn care uses none at all, while organic-based lawn care adds the safest effective control products and cuts pesticide use by up to 90%.

The two terms sound almost the same, so it is easy to assume they mean the same thing. They don't. At Simply Safer Premium Lawn Care, we offer both as separate programs. Our Organic-Based Program is our original program, built for a beautiful lawn with optimal control of weeds and insects. Our Organic Program relies only on natural, OMRI listed products.

Below we break down what goes into each approach, how that changes the results you see, and the questions homeowners ask us most about the difference.

Why Organic and Organic-Based Get Mixed Up

"Organic" has become a catch-all word in lawn care, and "organic-based" sounds like it should mean nearly the same thing. If you are comparing lawn care companies, it is worth asking exactly which products go down on your lawn.

Here is the short version. An organic program skips synthetic fertilizers and weed and insect control entirely. An organic-based program is not 100% organic. It uses targeted control products where they make the biggest difference, chosen for safety, so you get stronger weed, crabgrass, and grub control with far less pesticide than a typical program.

What Goes Into Each Approach

The clearest way to see the difference is to look at how each program handles the same jobs.

The job Organic-Based Program Organic Program
Feeding the lawn High-quality fertilizers through the season, plus a winterizer OMRI listed organic fertilizers and compost tea
Soil health Limestone with humic to reduce acidity and free up nutrients Organic fertilizers that build up in the soil and encourage microbial activity along with limestone and humic
Preventing crabgrass and weeds Pre-emergent applications in early and late spring Corn Gluten Meal in early spring
Grubs and insects Acelepryn, guaranteed grub prevention Grandevo PTO, a naturally derived bioinsecticide
Weeds already growing Post-emergent weed and crabgrass control with each seasonal fertilization Reduced over time by thickening the lawn, with optional Fiesta, an iron-based product that targets broadleaf weeds (Fiesta does not treat crabgrass)

The biggest gap is weed prevention. In the early and late spring, while soil temperatures are ideal, our Organic-Based Program applies pre-emergent treatments that help stop crabgrass and certain broadleaf weeds before they begin growing, and targeted weed and crabgrass control continues through the season with each fertilization. Instead of a pre-emergent herbicide, our Organic Program uses Corn Gluten Meal in the early spring. It has shown crabgrass and weed preventative properties, and it is very high in naturally occurring nitrogen, which greens up the lawn. It is a gentler tool, so an organic lawn relies more on thick, healthy turf to keep weeds out.

That is why the results feel different. The Organic-Based Program gives you optimal control through the season, while the Organic Program keeps your lawn green and reduces weeds over time as the soil improves and the turf thickens.

How We Run Each Program at Simply Safer

Our Organic-Based Program follows a seasonal schedule from early spring through the fall. It uses the best fertilizers and pH controls and the safest, most effective products available, and it reduces pesticide use by up to 90%. For grubs we use Acelepryn, which is classified as EPA Reduced Risk and is safe for your family, pets, bees, birds, and fish. Our lawns are greener and healthier, with noticeably fewer weeds and crabgrass.

Our Organic Program uses no synthetic pesticides or fertilizers, just years of experience and quality organic products applied at the right time. It keeps your lawn green, controls grub damage, and reduces weeds over time. Our OMRI listed organic fertilizers build up in the soil and encourage microbial activity, which helps the lawn grow stronger over time. Many of the products we use are produced locally, which reduces pollution and supports local jobs. Aeration and overseeding is a critical step in this program, because a thick lawn is how an organic yard naturally chokes out weeds and crabgrass.

What the Organic-Based Program Includes

  • Early spring fertilization to start the lawn growing greener and stronger, with weed and crabgrass control.
  • Early spring limestone with humic to reduce soil acidity and make more nutrients available, which strengthens the turf and naturally weakens weeds and crabgrass.
  • Late spring fertilization to prepare the lawn for summer heat, with weed and crabgrass control.
  • Grub proofing with Acelepryn, which is guaranteed to prevent grub damage, is classified as EPA Reduced Risk, and is safe for your family, pets, bees, birds, and fish.
  • Summer fertilization, a gentle feeding during the summer stress period with a focus on weed and crabgrass control.
  • Late summer and early fall fertilization to help the lawn recover from heat and humidity and develop deeper roots.
  • Aeration and overseeding, a critical step because it repairs thin areas and helps the grass naturally choke out weeds and crabgrass.
  • Winterizer and Limestone to support repair and root growth through the fall and a quicker green-up in spring and reduce soil acidity.

What the Organic Program Includes

  • Corn Gluten Meal in early spring for natural green-up and some crabgrass and weed prevention.
  • Late spring fertilization to prepare the lawn for summer heat
  • Summer fertilization, a gentle feeding during the summer stress period
  • Organic late summer/early fall compost-tea fertilization to keep the lawn healthy through summer stress and into early fall. If your lawn goes dormant, it also helps it recover more quickly.
  • Organic grub treatment with Grandevo PTO, a bioinsecticide made from a naturally occurring soil bacterium and proven to control chinch bugs, sod webworms, and several species of grubs.
  • Aeration and overseeding, a critical step for an organic lawn because it repairs thin areas and helps the grass naturally choke out weeds and crabgrass.
  • Winterizer and Limestone to support repair and root growth through the fall and a quicker green-up in spring and reduce soil acidity.

Many of our Organic Program customers also add our organic Fiesta broadleaf weed control each year. It is a late spring application that knocks down clover, dandelions, and other broadleaf weeds. Fiesta does not control crabgrass, so it is a helpful add-on rather than a replacement for the weed and crabgrass control built into the Organic-Based Program.

You can see many of the products we use on our lawn care products page.

What the Difference Means for Your Lawn

Results build at different speeds. With the Organic-Based Program, most customers notice a greener lawn within the first few treatments, and the biggest improvements come over the first full season. With the Organic Program, the lawn stays green while weeds decrease gradually as the soil comes back to life, so patience pays off. With either program, fall aeration and overseeding speeds things up.

Fall seeding matters more for an organic lawn. Every lawn benefits from fall aeration and overseeding, but an organic lawn depends on it. A thick lawn is the best natural defense against weeds. In Massachusetts and Rhode Island, the best window is late summer through early fall, while the soil temps are optimal and the seed has time to establish before winter. Our fall lawn recovery tips explain what to expect.

Your habits help either way. Mowing high and watering deeply build stronger roots and a thicker lawn, which makes any program work better. Taller grass shades the soil and crowds out weeds, and deep, less frequent watering encourages roots to grow deeper.

Questions to Help You Decide

Most homeowners who ask us about this are weighing two things. They want a lawn that looks great, and they want it to be safe for their kids, their pets, and the local environment. Both of our programs are built with safety in mind. The real question is how you balance weed and crabgrass control against avoiding synthetic pesticides entirely.

  • How much do weeds and crabgrass bother you? If you want them under tight control, the Organic-Based Program is the stronger choice.
  • Is a yard free of synthetic pesticides your top priority? If so, the Organic Program was designed for you.
  • Are you comfortable with gradual progress? An organic lawn reduces weeds over time as the soil and turf get healthier.
  • Are you planning to aerate and overseed in the fall? It helps any lawn, and it is especially important for an organic lawn.

A Few Common Questions

Is organic-based lawn care 100% organic?

No. Our Organic-Based Program uses carefully selected, effective products, including targeted weed, crabgrass, and grub control, and it reduces pesticide use by up to 90%. If you want a lawn program with no synthetic pesticides at all, that is our separate Organic Program.

Which program is better at controlling weeds and crabgrass?

The Organic-Based Program. It includes pre-emergent applications in the spring and weed and crabgrass control throughout the season. The Organic Program reduces weeds over time, mostly by building healthier soil and a thicker lawn. You can read more in our summer weed control article.

Do both programs protect my lawn from grubs?

Yes, in different ways. The Organic-Based Program uses Acelepryn for guaranteed grub prevention. The Organic Program uses Grandevo PTO, a bioinsecticide made from a naturally occurring soil bacterium that controls grubs, chinch bugs, and sod webworms.

What does OMRI listed mean?

OMRI is the Organic Materials Review Institute, a nonprofit that reviews products to confirm they are suitable for organic use. The fertilizers in our Organic Program are OMRI listed.

What is Corn Gluten Meal?

Corn Gluten Meal is a natural byproduct of corn processing. We apply it in early spring in our Organic Program. It is very high in naturally occurring nitrogen helping to kick start the lawn and green it up. It has also shown some crabgrass and weed suppressing properties to help with weed reduction.

Is Acelepryn an organic product?

No, but it is one of the safest grub control products available. Acelepryn is classified as EPA Reduced Risk, is guaranteed to prevent grub damage, and is safe for your family, pets, bees, birds, and fish. Our Organic Program uses Grandevo PTO, a bioinsecticide made from a naturally occurring soil bacterium, instead.

What does lime do?

Limestone is a naturally occurring compound of calcium and magnesium that helps balance your soil's pH. Both of our programs include an early spring and fall application of limestone with humic, which reduces soil acidity and makes more nutrients available to your grass.

Will an organic lawn have more weeds?

At first, it may. The Organic Program reduces weeds over time rather than all at once, mostly by building healthy soil and a thicker lawn. Many Organic Program customers add our organic Fiesta broadleaf weed control in late spring to knock down clover and dandelions. Fiesta does not control crabgrass.

Are both programs safe for kids and pets?

The Organic Program uses no synthetic pesticides or fertilizers at all and there are no restrictions for staying off of your lawn after an application. The Organic-Based Program was designed with safety in mind, reduces pesticide use by up to 90%, and uses carefully selected products like Acelepryn. After each visit, your technician will give you specific instructions based on that day's application.

Which program does Simply Safer recommend?

For the most beautiful lawn with the fewest weeds, we recommend our Organic-Based Program. If avoiding synthetic pesticides entirely is your top priority, our Organic Program is the safest option we offer. We are happy to look at your lawn and help you decide.

Want Help Figuring Out Which Approach Fits Your Yard?

Simply Safer is veteran owned and operated, and we have been caring for lawns across Massachusetts and Rhode Island for 25 years. Tell us what matters most to you, and one of our technicians can take a look at your lawn and recommend the program that makes the most sense for your yard, with no obligation. Give us a call at 1-866-GO-SAFER (467-2337) or contact us for a free quote.